Wolves in Shepherd's Clothing

Bjørn: Why are you doing this?

Patrick: Because you let me. —From Speak No Evil (2022)

The greatest films always leave themselves open to a number of interpretations, and the newly released horror movie, Heretic, is no different. Terrifying, thrilling, and oddly funny in spots, the ending leaves you wondering what it all meant, what you’re supposed to do now, and if you’re like me, will probably leave you wanting a second viewing.

Most of the YouTube commentariat has rendered the firm verdict that Heretic is a plain-faced attack on organized religion, a misogynist institution designed solely for men’s benefit and women’s detriment. The thriller is just the set dressing for the message, they say.

You might be surprised to hear me say this after last week’s article, but I disagree.

Heretic begins with two fresh-faced Mormon missionaries going door to door attempting to convert people to their church. Unlike many evangelical organizations whose missionaries are comprised of elder married couples (often with grown children), the Mormon church sends young adults—pairs of boys or girls—most of whom are naive, untested, and unused to the vulgarity of the secular world.

Sister Barnes and Sister Paxton (their first names are never given and these girls never address each other by their Christian names) arrive at the door of Mr. Reed (first name also never given), ready to answer all his questions about the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints.

After coming into his home, only after being assured his wife is baking a pie in the next room, Mr. Reed offers them soft drinks and says, “I think it is GOOD to be religious.”

We find out later in the movie that, yes, he most certainly does think it is good to be religious. For the girls anyway. For his prey.

The question is why.

Written by

Share

Copied